Customize your website

Labrador sees big drop in salmon numbers



Jenny McCarthy
Published on August 23, 2010
Published on August 23, 2010
Jenny McCarthy  RSS Feed

The numbers are in and salmon returns this year in Quebec and Atlantic Canada broke records—with the exception of Labrador and Conne River. In Labrador, numbers are down by as much as 75 percent in some areas.

Topics :
Atlantic Salmon Federation , Atlantic Salmon Advisory committee , Labrador , Sand Hill River , English River

In the three rivers in Labrador where counting took place—the English River, which branches out of Lake Melville; the Sand Hill River between Cartwright and Black Tickle; and the Paradise River,—the counts went down 10 percent, 58 percent and 56 percent respectively. The numbers are compared to the five-year average.

The number of large salmon for the Sand Hill River went down by more than 75 percent. Salmon there went down from 4696 to 1930, 

Bill Taylor, president of the Atlantic Salmon Federation said the numbers are worrying.

“These figures certainly raise concerns about what’s going on in Labrador,“ he said.

Mr. Taylor said there may be several factors in this decline but that the obvious factor when it comes to Labrador is the impact of the various Labrador fisheries.

The Innu, Inuit and Métis fisheries are interceptory fisheries, which means they intercept fish that are bound for a lot of different rivers in Labrador.

These fisheries are also net fisheries.

“It’s obvious when the only area in all of eastern Canada which is showing a downward trend is Labrador and that’s the only place where you have coastal net fisheries,” he said.

“It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure it out.”

“The nets don’t differentiate between male and female or large salmon and small salmon,” Mr. Taylor said.

“That impacts negatively on conservation, no question.”

These fisheries often take place in the estuaries and along the coast. Mr. Taylor said that is where the fish travel—close to the coastline and the fish in the estuaries are often bound for other rivers and are predominantly female, carrying the eggs for that particular river.

“Year after year after year, the impact of those fisheries are catching up with us and perhaps we are seeing the downturn because of that,” he said.

“There could be other factors at play, no question, but that is something that is man induced and can be addressed through better conservation and more precautionary management practices.”

He said there could also be environmental issues, and a predator- prey relationship at play.

Labrador has the only coastal salmon fishery in the province and in Atlantic Canada. The Metis are allocated 10 tonnes of salmon as a group. The same applies for the Inuit of Labrador. The Innu are allocated 2 tonnes of salmon.

"It’s obvious when the only area in all of eastern Canada which is showing a downward trend is Labrador and that’s the only place where you have coastal net fisheries" - Bill Taylor, president of the Atlantic Salmon Federation

Mr. Taylor said they recognize the right to fish by first nations and the right for food for social and ceremonial purposes. He said the first nations groups he has spoken to share his concerns.

 “If those fisheries continue to have the impact that they do, it won’t be long before there aren’t enough fish to fish for in Labrador anyway,” he said.

He said the Federation has been in talks with DFO and the various aboriginal groups about these issues.

Don Ivany is a member of the Atlantic Salmon Federation is Corner Brook. He said that at Atlantic Salmon Advisory committee meetings with DFO, the department has said that reporting from individual bands is not as good or as accurate as it has been in previous years.

He said there are measures that can be taken where everyone still has their fishing rights but some of the practices change.

Currently the net fishery involves Gill nets, which trap and kill anything that swims into it.

“We would like to see more selective types of nets so these fish could be caught alive,” he said.

Mr. Ivany also said it was a well-known fact that larger salmon tend to return to the rivers first.

“These are the ones we’d like to be protecting,” he said.

The larger the fish, Mr. Ivany explained, the more eggs they carry. One 10lb salmon would have twice the amount of eggs as a five-pound salmon.

A delay in the opening of the salmon fishery would protect these larger salmon and allow hundreds or thousands of fish to make it back to the river.

Mr. Ivany also said there are approximately 100 salmon rivers in Labrador. DFO only has counting facilities on three of these rivers.

“Good management is based on good scientific data,” he said.

“Because we don’t know, it’s not an excuse to harvest more.”

“We should be operating from a prevention point of view.

The Labradorian contacted DFO but they did not offer comment before publishing time.

 

Comments

  • Username
    Mark J. Sark
    - September 1, 2010 at 09:27:06

    There appears to be a pattern developing from certain recreational user groups, the Atlantic Salmon Federation (ASF) in particular who believes the way to address the Atlantic salmons decline is to simply blame aboriginals and their harvesting practices. While AFS’s approach is regrettable, its understandable given the climate in this country regarding aboriginal and treaty rights. The recent news article in “The Labaradorian” is also very disappointing if you’re a person who fishes not for sport or profit but to provide food to family members, elders and community members. Fishing has helped sustain my people for thousands of years, well before the arrival of the first Europeans. ASF President Bill Taylor’s recent comments does little to bring our people together to discuss solutions such as alternative harvesting practices, better monitoring, joint management harvesting plans and if necessary reduced efforts on landings which all sides including recreational fishers can agree on; solutions, which should be considered if we are to co-exist and have a resource left for our children. Each of us has a responsible role to play in maintaining healthy salmon stocks. Until recently, I applauded ASF’s efforts in reaching out to First Nations in addressing salmon management issues. But true salmon stewardship does not mean placing all the blame on First Nations, while recreational fishers continue to fish as usual simply because they represent the elite and privileged. Recently, I read an article, which appeared in the Globe and Mail that spoke to the issues regarding management of the sockeye salmon fishery in British Colombia. It was because of the work that First Nations put forward that DFO now wants to re-start the recreational fishery. A recreational and commercial fishery that’s been closed for nearly 50 years because of overfishing in large part by nonnative’s. Unfortunately this type of story is one that Canada does not want you to read or hear about so it doesn’t get printed. Naturally, DFO’s decision sparked outrage at the Okanagan Nation Alliance, a group of seven First Nations that has been spearheading a project to restore the salmon run for more than a decade. For the past six years, those efforts have included releasing millions of salmon fry into nearby rivers. While the federal government believes it has the right and “ultimate responsibility” for managing fisheries we are at a dangerous, unsustainable slide if we continue to allow resource management plans and policy be drawn up without First Nation consultation. Recreational and commercial fishing should never be placed at the same level as fishing for food, social and ceremonial purposes no matter how much money these user groups say they pump into the local economy. I look forward to the day when the issue regarding fisheries management is brought to the front and centre and into the courtroom where the issue regarding fishery management rightfully belongs. In conclusion, recreational fishing groups ASF in particular should stop with all the finger pointing and accusations that aboriginals are the main reason why Atlantic salmon stocks are declining in North America. Certainly there’s enough blame to go around for everyone including recreational fishers.

    Submit a Comment

  • Username
    david budgell
    - August 30, 2010 at 08:53:00

    you can publish this in your paper mr tayler and mr ivany dont have all the facts on the counting fences that were installed in labrador.the fences were installed to late in the year.the salmon were already going up the river before the fences were installed.due to high water the salmon did not stop they went on up the river.local people seen the salmon going up the rivers before the fences were installed,and said they wouldnt fly. if these men are worried about the salmon spend some time on the rivers and stop the rich people here in there labrador playground who are catching and killig 25 to 30 salmon a day per rod.nobody is monitoring this fishery.the fish are almost dead when released with split tales and cant make it up the rivers to spawn.also catch and release should be stopped,a lisence should be for 4 fish when they are caught and tagged get off the river,this would save thousand s of salmon. if you dont agree with my statement about the amount of fish being caught and released on the rivers you havent been there to see it ,to bad for the salmon,and people who cant enjoy the taste of the salmon who get in the strong tide die and sink to the bottom .

    Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

Submit a Comment

This form is NOT used for emailing the article to a friend. Please use the "Send to a friend" link at the top of the page for that purpose.

The Labradorian is not responsible for posted comments. Please be polite and confine your comments to the subject of the posted story. If you have an account, please sign on to it..

(we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

loading...

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Labradorian Twitter

Advertising